| Platinum | Pizza Hoss |
| Gold | A Dopo Sourdough Pizza |
| Silver | Baker Boy Pizza |
| Bronze | Mellow Mushroom Knoxville |
| Top Pick | Elidios's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gondolier Italian Restaurant & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Harby's Pizza & Deli |
| Top Pick | Jets |
| Top Pick | Pizza Palace |
| Top Pick | Twin Peaks |